Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Lies, Damned Lies, and Treasury Statements

Pick the bit you like...

As the Bloke keeps telling everyone, "his" paper for the TPA on the Great British Taxpayer Rip-Off made the front page lead in the Daily Express, as well as featuring in numerous other organs.

Yes, yes, OK, we're all very impressed, I'm sure. But having now been forced to peruse his wretched press cuttings for about the twentieth time, what really strikes us is the Treasury's dismissive comments on the paper. For example, asked about his calculation that Labour has racked up the real tax burden by 51%, HMT responded:

"Tax as a percentage of GDP is around the same level as it was in 1997 and is well below the peak of the 1980s. As a result of tax and benefit changes since 1997, four in ten families pay no net tax and this year's council tax increase is the lowest for over a decade."

Which is a classic series of non-sequiturs and half-truths that's well worth unpacking:

  1. On their own figures, tax as percentage of GDP is not "about the same level" as in 1997: it's about 1% higher, or about £15bn pa, and while that may be trivial to HMT, it represents £600 pa per household, a considerable burden on the average family.
  2. While it is true that the tax ratio is "well below the peak of the 1980s" (38.7% in 1984), that peak reflected Thatcher clearing up the fiscal mess left by the last Labour government - taxes were hiked in 1981 in order to get the public finances back onto a sustainable long-term footing; however, looking over the whole 18 years of Tory government, the average tax/GDP ratio was 35.9%, a full 1% lower than what Brown grabbed last year (see chart above).
  3. "This year's council tax increase is the lowest for a decade"... hmm yes... but this year's increases in many other taxes, including Business Rates, are among the highest for a decade.

But the real doozy is the claim that "as a result of tax and benefit changes since 1997, four in ten families pay no net tax".

To start with, it's unclear quite what they mean: virtually everybody pays net tax of one kind or another. But let's assume they're basing their claim on the annual ONS analysis entitled The effects of taxes and benefits on household income. The latest one published shows that for 2005-06, the bottom four income deciles of working age households with children (ie four out of every ten "families") paid less in direct tax than they received in cash benefits.

In other words, they got back more in welfare cash from the government than they paid out in income tax, National Insurance, and Council Tax. Which, if you're happy to stretch language like a Treasury spinnner, is sort of equivalent to paying "no net tax" (setting aside all the other indirect taxes people pay, of course).

But, and this is A BIG BUT...

...back in 1997-98, before Gordo's huge and hideously complex tax and benefit changes, the proportion of families paying no net tax on this definition was... er... exactly the same: four out of every ten (see here). In other words, all Brown's costly tinkering has achieved precisely nothing. The exact opposite of what the Treasury implies.

Now, I know I've said it before, but let me assure you, HMT didn't used to be like this. Obviously it was always economical with information, but it never used to mislead on this scale.

Let's hope Osborne really means what he says about that independent fiscal monitoring office. We desperately need some official source we can more or less trust.

PS How come taxes, on 37% of GDP, are so much lower than spending, on 42%+? Come on, you know this. First, borrowing (aka deferred taxation) is now running at nearly 3% of GDP. And second, "other receipts" - not counted as taxes, but including all those ballooning public sector service charges - are now well over 2% of GDP. Taken together, they account for the 5% gap between tax and spend.

1 comment:

  1. Bạn cần giao hàng đến cho khách. Bạn cần tìm sử dụng dịch vụ giao hàng tận nơi. Yêu cầu của bạn về chất lượng và giá cả rất khắc khe. Đa số các công ty khác đều không làm bạn hài lòng.
    Hãy đến với Proship chúng tôi, đảm bảo bạn sẽ hài lòng. Với các dịch vụ vận chuyển như: chuyển hàng ra đà nẵng, cho thuê kho bãi, ký gửi hàng hóa, chuyển hàng đi Hà Nội.
    Đặc biệt hệ thống kho của chúng tôi đều thực hành tốt bảo quản thuốc tốt và đạt chuẩn gsp. Hãy thử sử dụng dịch vụ đảm bảo bạn sẽ hài lòng.