Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Blank Cheque


So just what are we taxpayers on the hook for? What exactly has the government's panic bank deposit guarantee announcement exposed us to (see this blog)?

Having trawled through the papers and official websites this morning, it's entirely unclear what's actually been agreed. The official HM Treasury merely repeats Darling's TV announcement:

"Should it be necessary, we, with the Bank of England, would put in place arrangements that would guarantee all the existing deposits in Northern Rock during the current instability in the financial markets."

"Put in place arrangements". Like what? Will all deposits be covered? Retail and wholesale? What about say a roll-over facility - is that a new deposit? The reality is probably that they have no idea.

Also, which institutions are covered by the broader guarantee? We only found out about that after Darling had spoken, when Treasury officials briefed journalists that "the same guarantee would extend to any other bank in a situation similar to Northern Rock, which asked the Bank of England for help after experiencing cash flow problems following the worldwide squeeze on credit." Had Darling simply forgotten to mention that huge extension, or hadn't it occurred to them until they were later asked?

The message - strongly reinforced by the bumbling performance of the FSA's chief executive on this morning's Today programme - is that they are making this up as they go along. All they know is that they will do whatever it takes to stop the nightly TV reports of Weimar Republic style panic in the streets.

But it's our money they're chucking around. We need to know what it will cost, even if they're beyond caring.

Let's assume the guarantee will only apply to UK bank deposits held by UK private sector residents. At present, they amount to around £2 trillion. So straight off the bat, Darling has signed us up to guarantee £2 trillion of deposits. That's a big Big Liability- even bigger than the £1.7 trillion debt mountain this government has already built up (see this blog).

But of course, they might argue the actual cost is not this total potential liability, but the value of the free insurance cover they're handing out.

In the absence of detail it's rather difficult to tell what this amounts to, but one indication might be the US deposit insurance scheme, which is being widely trawled as the model for us.

That's operated by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and guarantees most deposits up to $100,000 (£50,000), some up to $250,000. It's funded by insurance premia paid by the participating banks themselves.

Looking at the FDIC's latest report, we find that in 2006 it insured $4.1 trillion of deposits on a premium income of only $32m (a mere 0.0008% of deposits). Which sounds like a knock-down bargain- until you recognise the FDIC has been going since 1933 and has built up huge reserves over that time. They now stand at $50bn, still only 1.2% of deposits, but a pretty chunky war chest compared to the zero we have in the UK.

So what might that imply for us?

A straight read across from the US says taxpayers would need to put aside an immediate reserve of £25bn and an annual premium of £16m pa. Well, that's not too bad you think- why didn't we do it before?

But given all those panicking queues, and NR alone with twenty odd billion of retail deposits, that doesn't sound right, does it. Not nearly enough.

And of course, it isn't.

In reality, the FDIC's premium rates go up and down depending on recent loss experience. During the recent boom, losses have been minimal (zero actually). But back in the late eighties and early nineties recession, the losses racked up ($15bn in the worst year). The premia then went much higher. A read across from that experience suggests the implied premia costs here would currently be of the order of £4-5bn pa (equals 0.2%- 0.25% pa of £2trn).

Remember too that the FDIC guarantee is capped - Darling has given an open-ended guarantee no matter how big the individual deposit.

The bottom line is that we can't really tell how much of a blank cheque the government has written, because as per they haven't worked out what their "plan" actually entails in the real world. But as of now, he's increased public sector liabilities by around £2 trillion, and he's committed taxpayers to providing free insurance cover costing perhaps £5bn pa.

This morning's press says Bank Governor King will take the rap for this and will shortly be removed. But the real culprit has been keeping a very low profile in No 10. He's the one who split responsibility for managing bank stability between the Bank and the FSA, and he's the one who presided over Britain's debt explosion.

But we're the ones who will have to pay for it all.

4 comments:

  1. thuoc bo nao dành cho mọi lứa tuổi, muốn tăng cường trí nhớ. Vigrx Plus thuốc tăng kích thước cậu bé hiệu quả nhất dành cho nam giới. Đọc thêm bài viết để biết thêm thông tin vigrx plus co tot khong

    Sản phẩm mới của nhật bản thuốc đông trùng hạ thảo tenken cho sức khỏe bền bỉ theo năm tháng. Những loại sâm điều trị chứng mãn dục ở nam giới và hỗ trợ sắc đẹp cũng như sinh lý cho nam lẫn nữ được nhiều chuyên gia khuyên dùng là sâm alipas, Sâm angela. Nếu có như cầu xin liên hệ đến chúng tôi "Muathuoctot". Chúng tôi còn cung cấp nhiều mặt hàng khác dùng để bổ trợ cho sức khỏe như: calcium+600mg+++d3 , sữa rửa mặt neutrogena , thuốc elevit cho bà bầu.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bị khó ngủ là vấn đề đang xảy ra ngày càng nhiều trong xã hội ngày nay, bị khó ngủ phải làm sao ? Có nhiều cách trị khó ngủ như dùng thuốc , ăn món ăn trị khó ngủ ,.. Giảm cân không phải một sớm một chiều mà phải theo lộ trình dài hạn và khoa học , thực đơn giảm cân cấp tốc trong 1 tuần cũng là một trong số các cách giúp giảm cân hiệu quả. Trên thị trường hiện nay có nhiềuthuốc giải độc gan tốt , giúp giải độc gan hiệu quả và an toàn. Đau mắt đỏ là bệnh rất dể lây lan , vậy cách chữa bệnh đau mắt đỏ nhanh nhất bằng nhiều phương pháp khác nhau . Bỏng bô xe máy là hiệu tượng gặp nhiều nhất hiện , vậy bị bỏng bô xe máy kiêng ăn gì ? Những thực phẩm nên kiêng như hải sản , đồ tanh , trứng và các món gà và nếp ,...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bạn cần dịch vụ vận chuyển. Hãy đến với chúng tôi giao nhận 247. Với đa dạng các dịch vụ về vận chuyển có thể kể đến như: chuyển hàng từ Đài Loan về Việt Nam, gửi hàng từ úc về Việt Nam, ship hàng Đức về Việt Nam, chuyển hàng từ Hàn Quốc về Việt Nam giá rẻ...
    Ngoài ra chúng tôi còn có dịch vụ chuyển hàng từ pháp về việt nam. Nếu bạn ở Việt Nam và cần chuyển ra nước ngoài thì đã có dịch vụ chuyển hàng từ Việt Nam sang Đài Loannhận chuyển hàng từ Việt Nam sang Hàn Quốc để bạn sử dụng. Hãy liên hệ với chúng tôi khi cần nhé.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The message - strongly reinforced by the bumbling performance of the FSA's chief executive on this morning's Today programme order cheque

    ReplyDelete